Monday, August 23, 2010

Would You Give Your Family Supplements?

There are three things in life we cannot escape:  
Death, Taxes..................................................... and the Direct Salesman
(Cymbals clang... "Thank you, Thank you! Yes, I love cheese...")

Honestly, if you're not an MLM (Multi-Level Marketing) distributor, you would have at least been approached by a stranger, friend or a relative who is one. Every company would claim that theirs is the miracle product, helps you lose weight, can cure all sorts of illnesses, beautify you from inside out, prevent dread diseases and etc etc etc. Some of the direct salespeople that have approached me and my family are from brands like Amway, Melilea, Cosway, Herbalife, Forever Living, Transfer Factor, Usana... to name a few. 

Although we have tried some, my husband is a stubborn skeptic while I sit on the fence on this matter. We have always maintained that as long as we eat a healthful and balanced diet, we should be doing alright. Right?

So I asked some friends of ours over dinner last night. They are mature parents with three kids. Straight away they gave a resounding "YES! Health supplements work!" The husband said that due to his less-than-healthy lifestyle when he was much younger, he should be stricken with some form of illnesses by now. But unlike some of his friends who are either sickly, unhealthy-looking, balding due to a lifestyle of excess, he claims that he is in good health (well, he is certainly healthy looking). He believes that if he were to stop taking these supplements, all illnesses would surface. His wife opined that our natural food is no better nowadays what with all the growth hormones injected into meat, pesticide-laced vegetables, chemical-ridden imported foods..etc. Plus, depending on how meticulous we are, vegetables also tend to lose their goodness during the course of preparation and cooking. Also, people tend to eat out a lot more due to work and convenience.  

Hmmm.....

Then, an article I came across got me wondering if we should perhaps balance our food intake with supplements after all. Check out Bizzarre Effects on Teens.

According to Dr Alice Prethima, she is seeing many cases of abnormalities in male and female teens due to the food chain and diet e.g. girls with too much hair where it shouldn't be and boys growing breasts (pic), a condition called gynecomastia. She further elaborated that we're eating too much meat and meat contain growth hormones previously injected into the animals. 

Besides that, bad oestrogens enter our bodies from:
a) Plastic materials e.g. fizzy bottled drinks
b) Polysterene containers when we pack food
c) Plastic bags/wrappers which are used to wrap food e.g. roti canai, curry, laksa...etc
d) Pesticides, insecticides and other bad oestrogenic substances in the environment.


It is a scary thought isn't it? That the food we take could potentially cause our sons to have breasts and daughters to be hairy.

Perhaps supplements aren't such a bad idea after all? Unless you're a farmer or you grow your own vegetables, it seems 'natural' foods nowadays aren't so natural: Meat with hormones, vegetables with pesticide, fish with mercury, dairy products with melamine...etc. I worry for our children!

What do you reckon?

More on:
Why Supplements are Good for You. 
Are Vitamins and Mineral Supplements Good for You? 
Safety of Herbal Supplements 
Enhanced by Zemanta

13 comments:

laifchan said...

Yup, to supplement or not to supplement?

I am taking supplements myself, but am pretty cautious and avoid stuff that have dubious claims ie extracts form certain berries with super high antioxidant levels that have anti-cancer claims (too much of a good thing is not so good)

Those against any form of supplements usually argue that a balanced diet negates the need for any supplements.
'Aiya, look at grandmother, survive on ikan bilis, fruits and vege and died at the ripe old age of 90+, no need all these expensive pills-lah!'

Well, unfortunately, our fish, vege & fruits don't seem to have the same amount of nutrients they used to in the past due to pollution, over-farming, pesticides, genetic-engineering etc.

And, our lifestyles now are more sedentary and generally less healthy than our predecessors.

I'm taking the recommended doses of essential vitamins & minerals plus omega-3 fatty acids from USANA, a pretty reputable brand. Hehe, my opinion here may be biased because a relative is an MLM agent for USANA :)

As long as I'm still breast-feeding, I'm also taking a bit more Calcium (caution on this as too much is not advisable, check with your doctors on an individual basis)as I just can't stand taking dairy products and don't take fish everyday.

Personally, I do experience less fatigue and being less prone to falling sick after taking supplements, but then again, many factors are involved here ie exercise, stress level, adequate sleep etc.

It is wise to stick to a reputable brand as issues of contamination ie mercury in fish oil carry adverse effects that far outweigh the benefits of additional nutrients from supplements.

So, do take supplements with both eyes and ears wide open...

Mad About Writing said...

Hmmm.. honestly, it's so hard to distinguish what is a more trusted brand.

We were introduced to one brand recently and of course, it sounded so attractive that we were almost sold. Then we did some research and read that in the past, this particular brand had its products recalled in the past due to high content of lead..
And it's not just one site that says that..
so we're kinda back to square one on this.

So i'm wondering,how do we know from the ingredients if those pills are of 'natural' origins.. I'm no chemist, but i get a bit worried when the ingredients do not list fruits/vege origins and it has things like *** oxide, *** dioxide... does that mean they're synthetics? as in not natural, chemically engineered to
'copy' the real thing?

so hard to decide on a brand that is really trustable.. I wouldn't want to end up with some side effects a few years later..

Ss said...

Becky,

May we know what brand are you referring to so that we can be aware too?

Mad About Writing said...

Ss, it's one of the brands I listed. But when i asked the distributor again, he said it's because a certain person posted malicious things abt the company. According to him, he was arrested for it.

Oh well... i think a better way to verify is still to ask ppl who are actually taking it... preferably for a few years to see its effects.

laifchan said...

Did a search on mercury in fish and breastfeeding and found this article in babycentre quite informative http://www.babycenter.com/0_eating-fish-when-youre-breastfeeding-how-to-avoid-mercury-an_10319858.bc?showAll=true.

The link to the wallet and reference card gives a nice summary of what fish is apparently safe acc. to FDA when pregnant or breastfeeding and also young children.

However, the info is skewed towards America, as usual , lack of local data.

Did find a local scientific article in 1997 but its far from reassuring. Most popular local fiah ie ikan kembung (Indian Mackeral) and tenggiri (spanish mackeral) can have >50% organic mercury!

So how? Well, it seems the bigger, deep sea fish are worse culprits as they can accumulate more mercury.

From the guidelines, the consensus seems to show that anchovies (ikan bilis) is the best bet for being rich in omega-3 fatty acids and lowest in mercury (yeah, granny was rite!)Tilapia is also listed as ok in the wallet card, its local, rite?

If budget permits, imported fish like salmon (wild is the best, farmed may contain other harmful chemicals) and cod are also good.

Hmmm,.. i'd better consult my mum-in-law on how to make ikan bilis stock and skip the planned seafood dinner in a nearby restaurant....

As for omega-3 supplements, most people also agree that its safest to stick to fish source from US, their stricter with mercury levels. The brand that I use claims to have the lowest levels, if none. It seems the company halted stock when there was no available fish source with safe levels.

As for the rest of the vits and minerals form the same brand, the difference claimed is better absorption due to the combination in each tablet ie Calcium with activated Vit D, magnesium etc. Again, the same caveat of possible bias on my part :)
Any dieticians out there who would like to comment?

Becky, it would be of great help if you could post the links of the purported lead in the brand of supplements so that we could have a look for ourselves

Mad About Writing said...

These sites state the 'cons' of the brand.

http://www.consumeraffairs.com/nutrition/herbalife.html

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20060708105252AAXZ6eA

http://wiki.answers.com/Q/Is_it_safe_to_use_herbalife_products

http://www.livestrong.com/article/182962-are-there-any-bad-side-effects-to-using-herbalife/

http://www.herbal-lead.com/

http://www.uslaw.com/library/Litigation/Herbalife_products_contain_unsafe_levels_lead.php?item=145404

http://www.blizzardlaw.com/PracticeAreas/Herbalife.asp


Sites below claim 'pros' of it:

http://bloghealthydiet.com/herbalife-scam/

http://www.herbalvitality.info/aw/FAQ.htm

http://smoothjazzandmore.blogspot.com/2008/03/does-herbalife-work.html

http://www.diet-blog.com/05/herbalife_whats_the_deal.php


Well, you guys read and judge for yourselves. I think there will always be people who say don't believe everything you read on the Internet. Question is which part do you disbelieve? Should we disbelieve those who praise it too? Or only the critics?

Therefore, I think it is still better if I can ask people who have actually used it for a while...

Mad About Writing said...

hey laifchan, thanks for sharing the info about the fish...

tho i wonder why the fish u listed are found with such high content of mercury....so does that mean freshwater fish is better?

So it's anchovies after all, huh? Hmm.. not my favourite but guess one can always change for health's sake.

laifchan said...

not sure whether river fish is safer, me thinks its gotta do with level of pollution and contamination, whether river or sea.

I think i won't give up eating ikan bakar (ikan pari), my favoutite grouper or pomfret now and then, but prob won't eat fish on a daily basis.

Don't think I can survive on ikan bilis alone too :)

On a semi-related subject, was surveying the different brands of formula and finally decided to give Enfagrow a shot. Hehe, I think they have a good marketing strategy on the 4x DHA thingy-still doesn't quite meet the recommended dietary requirements so source from solid foods still important.

My boy is already pretty active (?DHA supplement enriched breastmilk), lets see whether he becomes more hyper on Enfa...

Mad About Writing said...

did you taste it yourself?
do you think it tastes sweet? like really, really, REALLY sweet?

alicia said...

err.. anyone knows what is the english translation for 'ma yau' (cantonese) fish?? have been feeding jamie with it 2 servings a day past 7 months! hope it's safe for consumption. my mum doesn't want to give chicken as she says it has hormones, beta agonist etc and pork too...sigh...mybe i should just mix a bit of everything to even out the possible toxicity!!

karene lee said...

To supplement or not to supplement?
Instead of taking pills and tablets, I would say it is better to opt for foods enriched in these vitamins and minerals rather than their concentrated forms of supplements. Good example are milk like Ensure form Abbott, Nutrien Optimum from Nestle and Enercal Plus from Wyeth which has been discontinued. Besides the micronutrients (v and m), it also provides macronutrients (carbs, proteins and good fats in a proper ratio. Other good choices are morning cereals and muesli. Beware of any supplements with content/dosage of 10x higher than the recommended intake.

karene lee said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Mad About Writing said...

BTW, people. Karene is a professional dietician...

Thanks , Karene! :)